Template:StarCupRecords AllTime PostseasonWins

Rank	Team	League	Postseason W	All-Time Postseason W-L	Postseason W Pct
1	Aptos Investigators	Monterey Bay	33	33-45	42.31 %
2	Sand City Sidewinders	Monterey Bay	29	29-33	46.77 %
3	Pacific Grove Monarchists	Monterey Bay	26	26-31	45.61 %
4	Richmond Slicks	San Francisco Bay	20	20-33	37.74 %
5	Berkeley Brutalists	San Francisco Bay	18	18-35	33.96 %
6	Santa Cruz Bananas	Monterey Bay	16	16-32	33.33 %
6	San Jose Avionics	San Francisco Bay	16	16-33	32.65 %
7	Hayward Pipelines	San Francisco Bay	15	15-30	33.33 %
8	Freedom Fries	Monterey Bay	14	14-27	34.15 %
9	Monterey Meteorologists	Monterey Bay	13	13-16	44.83 %
9	Davenport Cliff Divers	Monterey Bay	13	13-25	34.21 %
9	Vallejo Barnstormers	San Francisco Bay	13	13-29	30.95 %
10	Carmel Yacht Club	Monterey Bay	12	12-20	37.50 %
10	Oakland Bees	San Francisco Bay	12	12-20	37.50 %
11	Mountain View Miners	San Francisco Bay	11	11-34	24.44 %
12	Sausalito Bouncy Castles	San Francisco Bay	10	10-23	30.30 %
13	San Gregorio Sand Crabs	San Francisco Bay	8	8-14	36.36 %
13	Boulder Creek Cardsharps	Monterey Bay	8	8-19	29.63 %
13	Sutro Tower	San Francisco Bay	8	8-29	21.62 %
14	Moss Landing Daredevils	Monterey Bay	7	7-19	26.92 %