Template:SeasonBySeason HellmouthIIICup TB

In Hellmouth III/Season 1 the Tucson Butchers were the #1 seed in the Cold League.
- They lost the Cold League Division Series to the Seattle Sneakers 2-3.
In Hellmouth III/Season 4 the Tucson Butchers were the #2 seed in the Cold League.
- They defeated the Sacramento Boot Lickers 3-1 in the Cold League Division Series.
- They clinched the pennant by defeating the Long Beach Flightless Birds 4-3 in the Cold League Championship Series.
- They lost the Hellmouth III Cup Series to the Delaware Corporate Shells , 2-4.
In Hellmouth III/Season 5 the Tucson Butchers were the #2 seed in the Cold League.
- They lost the Cold League Division Series to the Sacramento Boot Lickers 1-3.
In Hellmouth III/Season 8 the Tucson Butchers were the #1 seed in the Cold League.
- They lost the Cold League Division Series to the Phoenix Freshrolls 2-3.
In Hellmouth III/Season 13 the Tucson Butchers were the #4 seed in the Cold League.
- They lost the Cold League Division Series to the Albuquerque Solarpunks 2-3.
In Hellmouth III/Season 15 the Tucson Butchers were the #1 seed in the Cold League.
- They defeated the Sacramento Boot Lickers 3-1 in the Cold League Division Series.
- They lost the Cold League Championship Series to the Long Beach Flightless Birds 2-4.
In Hellmouth III/Season 16 the Tucson Butchers were the #3 seed in the Cold League.
- They lost the Cold League Division Series to the Long Beach Flightless Birds 2-3.