| Rank | Season | Team | Postseason W-L | Points Scored | Points Allowed | 
| 1 | S6 |  Sacramento Boot Lickers | 11-1 | 5,157 | 1,957 | 
| 2 | S5 |  Alewife Arsonists | 11-3 | 5,153 | 2,947 | 
| 3 | S9 |  Elko Astronauts | 11-4 | 5,388 | 3,484 | 
| 4 | S1 |  Sugar Grove Eavesdroppers | 11-6 | 6,355 | 4,315 | 
| 5 | S7 |  Albuquerque Solarpunks | 11-6 | 5,319 | 4,676 | 
| 6 | S8 |  Boylston Boogers | 11-6 | 5,284 | 4,760 | 
| 7 | S4 |  Sugar Grove Eavesdroppers | 11-7 | 6,254 | 4,698 | 
| 8 | S2 |  Sacramento Boot Lickers | 11-8 | 6,972 | 4,660 | 
| 9 | S3 |  Salt Lake Turbulence | 11-8 | 6,628 | 5,479 | 
|  | 
| 10 | S7 |  Jersey OSHA Violations | 10-4 | 5,478 | 3,080 | 
| 11 | S3 |  Milwaukee Flamingos | 10-8 | 6,058 | 5,326 | 
| 12 | S5 |  Elko Astronauts | 10-8 | 4,837 | 5,953 | 
| 13 | S2 |  Boylston Boogers | 10-8 | 4,520 | 5,037 | 
|  | 
| 14 | S8 |  Sacramento Boot Lickers | 9-5 | 4,443 | 4,110 | 
| 15 | S1 |  Sacramento Boot Lickers | 9-7 | 5,161 | 4,917 | 
| 16 | S4 |  Albuquerque Solarpunks | 9-8 | 5,000 | 5,457 | 
|  | 
| 17 | S6 |  Milwaukee Flamingos | 8-5 | 3,881 | 3,689 | 
| 18 | S9 |  Sugar Grove Eavesdroppers | 8-6 | 4,272 | 4,158 | 
|  | 
| 19 | S5 |  San Diego Balloon Animals | 6-4 | 3,846 | 1,856 | 
| 20 | S4 |  Milwaukee Flamingos | 6-4 | 3,125 | 3,329 | 
| 21 | S3 |  Phoenix Freshrolls | 6-5 | 3,856 | 3,053 | 
| 22 | S1 |  Long Beach Flightless Birds | 6-5 | 3,621 | 3,033 | 
| 23 | S2 |  Baltimore Texas II | 6-6 | 3,594 | 3,905 | 
| 24 | S2 |  Detroit Grape Chews | 6-6 | 2,941 | 3,194 | 
|  | 
| 25 | S8 |  Fargo Flea Flickers | 5-5 | 3,183 | 2,955 | 
| 26 | S3 |  Sugar Grove Eavesdroppers | 5-5 | 2,743 | 3,346 | 
| 27 | S7 |  San Diego Balloon Animals | 5-5 | 2,581 | 3,054 | 
| 28 | S4 |  Salt Lake Turbulence | 5-6 | 3,327 | 3,287 | 
| 29 | S1 |  Detroit Grape Chews | 5-6 | 2,825 | 3,422 | 
|  | 
| 30 | S8 |  Long Beach Flightless Birds | 4-5 | 3,169 | 2,544 | 
| 31 | S6 |  Alewife Arsonists | 4-5 | 2,455 | 2,706 | 
| 32 | S9 |  Long Beach Flightless Birds | 4-6 | 3,178 | 2,762 | 
|  | 
| 33 | S7 |  Detroit Grape Chews | 3-4 | 1,911 | 2,307 | 
| 34 | S6 |  Baltimore Texas II | 3-4 | 1,901 | 2,557 | 
| 35 | S5 |  Jersey OSHA Violations | 3-6 | 2,100 | 3,251 | 
| 36 | S9 |  Alewife Arsonists | 3-6 | 2,074 | 3,240 | 
|  | 
| 37 | S9 |  Detroit Grape Chews | 2-3 | 1,608 | 1,368 | 
| 38 | S4 |  San Diego Balloon Animals | 2-3 | 1,570 | 1,687 | 
| 39 | S8 |  Detroit Grape Chews | 2-3 | 1,541 | 1,443 | 
| 40 | S9 |  Tucson Butchers | 2-3 | 1,492 | 1,634 | 
| 41 | S2 |  Long Beach Flightless Birds | 2-3 | 1,456 | 1,485 | 
| 42 | S5 |  San Francisco Boat Shoes | 2-3 | 1,456 | 1,550 | 
| 43 | S4 |  Long Beach Flightless Birds | 2-3 | 1,396 | 1,844 | 
| 44 | S4 |  Delaware Corporate Shells | 2-3 | 1,392 | 1,149 | 
| 45 | S3 |  Tucson Butchers | 2-3 | 1,391 | 1,534 | 
| 46 | S3 |  Vegas Vampires | 2-3 | 1,381 | 1,907 | 
| 47 | S1 |  Alewife Arsonists | 2-3 | 1,279 | 1,509 | 
| 48 | S9 |  Jersey OSHA Violations | 2-3 | 1,248 | 1,563 | 
| 49 | S2 |  Jersey OSHA Violations | 2-3 | 1,208 | 1,379 | 
| 50 | S2 |  Albuquerque Solarpunks | 2-3 | 1,172 | 1,751 | 
| 51 | S9 |  Phoenix Freshrolls | 2-3 | 1,047 | 2,098 | 
| 52 | S1 |  Delaware Corporate Shells | 2-3 | 945 | 1,513 | 
|  | 
| 53 | S8 |  Vegas Vampires | 1-3 | 1,139 | 1,424 | 
| 54 | S7 |  Tucson Butchers | 1-3 | 1,084 | 1,205 | 
| 55 | S5 |  Phoenix Freshrolls | 1-3 | 1,072 | 1,346 | 
| 56 | S6 |  Detroit Grape Chews | 1-3 | 1,070 | 1,427 | 
| 57 | S3 |  Jersey OSHA Violations | 1-3 | 1,065 | 1,466 | 
| 58 | S7 |  Seattle Sneakers | 1-3 | 967 | 1,275 | 
| 59 | S8 |  Albuquerque Solarpunks | 1-3 | 838 | 1,654 | 
| 60 | S1 |  Seattle Sneakers | 1-3 | 822 | 1,484 | 
| 61 | S2 |  Alewife Arsonists | 1-3 | 721 | 1,173 | 
| 62 | S3 |  Long Beach Flightless Birds | 1-3 | 627 | 1,638 | 
|  | 
| 63 | S6 |  Elko Astronauts | 0-3 | 708 | 1,204 | 
| 64 | S4 |  Boylston Boogers | 0-3 | 645 | 1,258 | 
| 65 | S8 |  Elko Astronauts | 0-3 | 570 | 1,277 | 
| 66 | S7 |  Milwaukee Flamingos | 0-3 | 569 | 1,268 | 
| 67 | S6 |  Albuquerque Solarpunks | 0-3 | 524 | 1,130 | 
| 68 | S6 |  Sugar Grove Eavesdroppers | 0-3 | 483 | 1,509 | 
| 69 | S1 |  Phoenix Freshrolls | 0-3 | 411 | 1,226 | 
| 70 | S5 |  Milwaukee Flamingos | 0-3 | 396 | 1,103 | 
| 71 | S7 |  Vegas Vampires | 0-3 | 383 | 1,427 | 
| 72 | S5 |  Albuquerque Solarpunks | 0-3 | 366 | 1,220 |